Equity, Diversity and Inclusion: Improving gender equity in academia depends on the workplace environment

  1. Sreetama Bhadra
  2. Gabriella Damasceno  Is a corresponding author
  3. Daniela Hoss
  4. Alexandra Weyrich
  1. German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research (iDiv), Halle-Jena-Leipzig, Germany
  2. Leipzig University, Germany
  3. Institute of Biology/Geobotany and Botanical Garden, Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Germany
  4. Evolutionary Genetics, Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research, Germany
1 table and 2 additional files

Tables

Table 1
Guidelines of specific steps to achieve acknowledgement, transparency and action.

At the level of individual researchers, the points in blue text indicate guidelines we performed and experienced within the iFS initiative; at the level of universities and research institutions, the points in blue text indicate topics in which the involvement of iFS resulted in improvements in equity at our institute; and at the level of policymakers, the points in blue text are topics we expect this paper can have an impact on. The points in black text are based on discussions we had with other women in science within iFS, on perspectives we see for the future, and on ideas we found in literature (such as Grogan, 2018 and Snickare et al., 2022).

Individual researchers
AcknowledgementTransparencyAction
Recognize the problem of gender inequity and become informed on how to tackle it:
  • Learn about the leaky-pipeline and scissors effect problems

  • Familiarize yourself with local initiatives addressing the problems, like equity committees

Increase collective awareness:
  • Foster discussions and workshops about biases and gender inequity

  • Spread information about local initiatives

Support women:
  • Nominate and vote women for leadership positions

  • Foster inclusivity criteria in hiring processes

Become aware of your own biases:
  • Attend unconscious bias workshops

  • Quantify gender bias among authors and author roles in your own manuscripts

Be open about your own biases:
  • Critically reflect on your own biases

  • Discuss biases with colleagues

Explicitly address biases:
  • Invite more women peers to collaborate

  • Suggest/ create a code of conduct” for your own group

Be attentive to your surroundings:
  • Calculate the proportion of women in the institution, especially in leadership positions

  • Become informed about regulations to handle discrimination and harassment complaints

Promote a friendlier environment:
  • Adopt an active by-stander behavior

  • Demand transparency in handling discrimination/ harassment complaints

Ensure a safer environment:
  • Adopt non-discriminatory language and practices

  • Intervene or report cases of discrimination/ harassment

Universities and research institutions
AcknowledgementTransparencyAction
Collect and acknowledge gender-disaggregated data:
  • About infrastructure, and financial and human resources available to employees

  • On staff productivity (funding, publication, career stage, career progression) in relation to the resources available to them

Increase awareness:
  • Make gender-disaggregated data available for staff on intranet or internet portals

  • Implement mandatory workshops about unconscious bias for employees

Reduce inequity:
  • Implement inclusive criteria for hiring women and adopt alternative metrics to evaluate their performance

  • (Re-)distribute resources with equity as the guiding criteria

Collect data on discrimination and harassment complaints:
  • Create periodic anonymous surveys for collecting data about discrimination/ harassment

  • Standardize the way data about discrimination/ harassment is collected at different sources, like departments and research groups

Share the data safely:
  • Inform staff about the due process for dealing with discrimination/harassment complaints

  • Report the outcomes of the due process (i.e., number of complaints, type of outcome) without disclosing identities of victims

Implement measures against discrimination/ harassment:
  • Establish a system of checks and balances to prevent power structures from interfering with the due process dealing with discrimination/ harassment

  • Implement a code of conduct establishing a clear and time-bound process in cases of discrimination/ harassment; preferably written together with people who are vulnerable to misconduct

Assess policies and plans towards equity:
  • Critically evaluate what has been implemented and achieved

  • Gain inspiration from successful initiatives

Plan together with the community to achieve gender equity:
  • Set up and publicize action plans with clear goals and milestones

  • Specify a timeframe for evaluation and revisions of plans

Guarantee implementation of plans:
  • Devote human and financial resources to implement and review the plans periodically

  • Reward departments who achieve the goals, and demand adaptation/ explanation from those who do not

Policymakers
AcknowledgementTransparencyAction
Gather and harmonize data about the problem:
  • Compile and harmonize gender-disaggregated data at the federal and national level, leveraging the data already collected by institutions and international organizations

  • Identify institutions and research fields in which actions towards equity are required

Create standards for data collection at institutions:
  • Create guidelines for data collection and report, with standardized terminology of career positions

  • Demand annual reports from institutions containing gender-disaggregated data

Set actions and goals to be taken by institutions:
  • Demand institutions to create plans and policies for gender equity

  • Mandate data sharing by institutions

Collect information about existing public policies targeted to gender inequity:
  • Critically assess existing policies, including evaluation and recommendations by experts

  • Assess how institutions and countries are performing in comparison to international guidelines for gender equity

Create an agenda of inclusivity:
  • Create plans for the development and implementation of regulations to deal with gender inequity

  • Establish a “reputation rank” for universities and institutions, ranking them regarding their support for women and equity initiatives

Establish regulations and legal frameworks to foster implementation of gender equity in science:
  • Create legal security for women in science, for example, paid maternity leave

  • Create support initiatives targeted to keep women in science, for example providing child-care spaces and allowing working flexibility to accommodate family-care duties

Inspect and review funding grants in relation to gender:
  • Gather gender disaggregated data on grant awardees, preferably by research fields and institutions

  • Inspect for biases in grant awards, including the type and amount of grants

Promote transparency in funding:
  • Publicize the number of grant applicants/nominees and awardees by gender and knowledge field

  • Disclose criteria used for grant awards, especially those preventing/ promoting gender equity

Create system of rewards and penalties for institutions:
  • Constrain awarding of grants to the success of institutions to implement gender equity measures

  • Create awards for gender equity initiatives

Additional files

Supplementary file 1

Questionnaire for evaluating the supportiveness of workplace environments.

https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/105352/elife-105352-supp1-v1.docx
Supplementary file 2

Collection of gender-disaggregated data.

https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/105352/elife-105352-supp2-v1.docx

Download links

A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.

Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)

Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)

Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)

  1. Sreetama Bhadra
  2. Gabriella Damasceno
  3. Daniela Hoss
  4. Alexandra Weyrich
(2025)
Equity, Diversity and Inclusion: Improving gender equity in academia depends on the workplace environment
eLife 14:e105352.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.105352