Paleobotany: Did flowering plants exist in the Jurassic period?
The discovery of a fossil that might be the oldest flowering plant will continue the debate on the origin and structure of ancestral flowering plants.
- Indiana University Southeast, United States
- Frostburg State University, United States
"This shouldn't be here," said Ellie, the paleobotanist in Jurassic Park, as she stared at a leaf. "This species of veriforman has been extinct since... the Cretaceous period." Ellie might have been equally impressed and surprised if she had stumbled across a fossil recently discovered in China that appears to be of a flowering plant that dates to the Jurassic period.
One of the characteristics of flowering plants is that they produce seeds within an ovary or carpel, which is why they are also called angiosperms (angio-, container; sperms, seeds). They became widespread during the Cretaceous period, and now come in about 300,000 different species and dominate most landscapes. Models based on comparisons of plant DNA changes over time (Magallón et al., 2015) and a study of geochemical biomarkers by the present authors and others (Taylor et al., 2006) suggest that angiosperms originated before the Cretaceous period (which started 145 million years ago), and perhaps even before the Jurassic period (which started 201 million years ago). However, unequivocal fossil evidence of angiosperms only dates back to 135 million years ago, well after the end of the Jurassic period. Moreover, recent reports of Jurassic flowers by Xin Wang of the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology and co-workers (which are summarized in Wang, 2017a; Wang, 2017b) and pollen have not been widely accepted (see Herendeen et al., 2017 for a review).
Now, in eLife, Xin Wang, Zhong-Jian Liu of the Orchid Conservation and Resesarch Center of Shenzhen and international co-workers – including Qiang Fu as first author and co-workers in Spain, Australia and other institutes in China – report evidence for an angiosperm from the Early Jurassic (Fu et al., 2018). They base this claim on the fact that this new species, which they have called Nanjinganthus, possesses the characteristics of the earliest angiosperms as published by Bateman, Hilton and Rudall in 2006 (Bateman et al., 2006). Here we discuss whether or not Nanjinganthus fulfills our criteria to be considered a Jurassic angiosperm, including whether it possesses the structural features that we would expect to find in an ancestral angiosperm.
First, the age and dating of the fossiliferous sediment must be reliable, and the fossils should be collected in situ by the researchers to ensure dependable placement and stratigraphy. Fu et al. collected numerous specimens of Nanjinganthus from localities with strong biostratigraphic dating to the Early Jurassic, so the finding passes this test. Second, the fossil species must have at least one agreed-upon defining characteristic (such as an ovary); moreover, any additional characteristics must not be a defining characteristic for any other group of living or fossil non-flowering seed plants (which are collectively known as gymnosperms). Nanjinganthus does exhibit strong evidence that the seeds are within an ovary, which falls within a rather narrow definition of an angiosperm (Wang, 2017a; Wang, 2017b), and Fu et al. conclude that the other characteristics of their specimens do not define any gymnosperm. Third, the fossil should have multiple characteristics of an angiosperm, and many of these should be consistent with the ancestral characteristics put forward by other researchers, based on studies of well-preserved fossils and modern plants. Given that Fu et al. discuss Nanjinganthus with respect to only a limited number of these characteristics, here we explore this criterion in more detail.
First, we examined the ancestral characteristics predicted by Peter Endress and James Doyle in 2009, based on a phylogenetic analysis of basal living angiosperms (Endress and Doyle, 2009). Based on our interpretation of the fossil, we found that 23 of 29 floral characteristics (79%) preserved in Nanjinganthus matched the predictions (Figure 1).
Figure 1
Characteristics of an ancestral flowering plant.
Floral diagram of the Jurassic fossil Nanjinganthus (left), and the characteristics for the flower, perianth and gynoecium of the ancestral flowering plant as predicted by Endress and Doyle (E&D), Sauquet et al. (S), and Taylor (T). The floral diagram is our interpretation of the fossil and it shows (starting at the outside): one bract and two fused bracteole (green); two scales (orange); a whorl of five sepals, which could be four (green); a second whorl of five petals, which again could be four (orange); five fused carpels (which could be four) forming an inferior ovary/epigynous flower (olive green and black) that contains two ovules/seeds (black triangles) that are attached to the outer walls of the ovary; it is also possible for there to be one or three ovules/seeds. The characteristics of Nanjinganthus shown in green in the three lists are consistent with Endress and Doyle, Sauquet et al., and Taylor; the characteristics shown in orange are only consistent with Taylor, and those shown in crimson are not consistent with any of these three sources. Floral diagram created with the Floral Diagram Generator at http://kvetnidiagram.8u.cz/odiagramech_en.php
Second, of the 13 characteristics predicted by the evolutionary-developmental model of Hervé Sauquet and co-workers (Sauquet et al., 2017), we found six (46%) in Nanjinganthus (Figure 1). However, the fossil has seven characteristics that were not predicted by either model. For example, the fossil has a complexly branched style/stigma attached on top of the ovary, surrounded four or five petals, and the seeds are attached on the middle of the carpel walls (Figure 1). Finally, we examined a suite of better-preserved, Early Cretaceous fossil species previously summarized by one of us (Taylor, 2010) and we found 15 of the 18 characteristics (83%) in Nanjinganthus (Figure 1). The only characteristics not found in these fossils were the presence of petals, fused ovary, and seed attached on the middle of the carpel wall (presence of branched style/stigma was not reported).
From this analysis, we infer that Nanjinganthus shows substantial similarity to predicted models of ancestral characters and Early Cretaceous angiosperms, so the evidence suggests that it is a Jurassic flowering plant. Nanjinganthus is clearly an important fossil, but additional characteristics need to be documented, the similarities to angiosperms need more careful justification, and its relationships to other species should be analyzed phylogenetically. Finally, the Jurassic angiosperms previously reported by Wang and co-workers could be reevaluated with our criteria to assess if they are missing angiosperms. New fossils and additional analyses will finally confirm the presence of angiosperms in the Jurassic period and strengthen our understanding of the ancestral angiosperm.
References
-
Reconstructing the ancestral angiosperm flower and its initial specializationsAmerican Journal of Botany 96:22–66.https://doi.org/10.3732/ajb.0800047
-
The ancestral flower of angiosperms and its early diversificationNature Communications 8:16047.https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms16047
-
BookImplications of fossil floral data on understanding the early evolution of molecular developmental controls of flowersIn: Gee C. T, editors. Plants in Mesozoic Time: Morphological Innovations, Phylogeny, Ecosystems. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. pp. 119–169.
-
A biased, misleading review on early angiospermsNatural Science 09:399–405.https://doi.org/10.4236/ns.2017.912037
Article and author information
Author details
David Winship Taylor
Publication history
Copyright
© 2018, Taylor and Li
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use and redistribution provided that the original author and source are credited.
Metrics
-
- 5,468
- views
-
- 398
- downloads
-
- 11
- citations
Views, downloads and citations are aggregated across all versions of this paper published by eLife.
Download links
A two-part list of links to download the article, or parts of the article, in various formats.
Downloads (link to download the article as PDF)
Open citations (links to open the citations from this article in various online reference manager services)
Cite this article (links to download the citations from this article in formats compatible with various reference manager tools)
Paleobotany: Did flowering plants exist in the Jurassic period?
eLife 7:e43421.
https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.43421
Further reading
-
Fossils found in China suggest that the first flowers emerged much earlier than previously thought.
-
- Evolutionary Biology
Lineages of rod-shaped bacteria such as Escherichia coli exhibit a temporal decline in elongation rate in a manner comparable to cellular or biological aging. The effect results from the production of asymmetrical daughters, one with a lower elongation rate, by the division of a mother cell. The slower daughter compared to the faster daughter, denoted respectively as the old and new daughters, has more aggregates of damaged proteins and fewer expressed gene products. We have examined further the degree of asymmetry by measuring the density of ribosomes between old and new daughters and between their poles. We found that ribosomes were denser in the new daughter and also in the new pole of the daughters. These ribosome patterns match the ones we previously found for expressed gene products. This outcome suggests that the asymmetry is not likely to result from properties unique to the gene expressed in our previous study, but rather from a more fundamental upstream process affecting the distribution of ribosomal abundance. Because damage aggregates and ribosomes are both more abundant at the poles of E. coli cells, we suggest that competition for space between the two could explain the reduced ribosomal density in old daughters. Using published values for aggregate sizes and the relationship between ribosomal number and elongation rates, we show that the aggregate volumes could in principle displace quantitatively the amount of ribosomes needed to reduce the elongation rate of the old daughters.
